Waukesha, WI Pizza Delivery - Michael's Italian Restaurant

    4 star review  Ordered a gluten free pizza to take home. It was made correctly, took about the amount of time they said it would, tasted good. 10" crust for the gluten free crust at a slightly different cost than the regular pizzas. Friendly staff who were able to answer questions on the phone. While walking in and out, the seating area was nice.

    thumb Carolyn Sehorn
    October 4, 2021

    4 star review  Im sorry, but we paid $70.00 per person for crab legs without a soup and salad. When I asked about soup or salad they said that was extra, really? So I have eaten at this restaurant on numerous occasions, but now it will cost you extra for a soup or salad, no thank you. Good luck with your restaurant

    thumb John Lang
    September 20, 2021

    4 star review  Classic Italian style restaurant. Dark wood, low light, corner booths. Great pizza! Traditional thin crust (but you could make it thick crust if you want) will definitely be back!

    thumb Joshua Mathew
    September 18, 2021

    5 star review  I ordered food for pickup and it was ready on time, the team packaged it up when I got there to confirm everything was there and the order was correct and the food was very good and hot.

    thumb Bob Love
    September 3, 2021

1400 S Grand Ave Waukesha, WI 53189

Pizza in Waukesha, WI


    review rating 5  This place never disappoints. Whenever we decide to go out to eat, inevitably this place is at least mentioned. It's my wife's favorite place to eat out and rapidly becoming mine. I don't recall ever having a bad experience with the service here. Host staff is always pleasant and your wait staff is the bomb. Always willing to have some side conversation with you. And I haven't even mentioned the food yet. I have tried many things on your menu and don't recall ever saying that I'd never order that again. I just wish I knew a little Italian so I didn't roach the names of your dinners every time I order. But we always leave full and satisfied. Only one thing, and not nearly enough to remove a star; can you update the carpet? Looks like it's a tad older than my 50 years.

    thumb Thomas VANDELEEST

    review rating 5  One word...Squisito!

    I did a search for best pizza in Wakesha and Micheal's came up. It did not disappoint. Delicious super supreme pizza and calamari as an app that had a perfect snap, telling sign it is fresh. Rebecca, our server, was exceptional and entertained all our comments about Wisconsin's hospitality. We will be back without a doubt to try everything on the menu.

    thumb Alaina Goss

    review rating 4  *´¨)
    ¸.· ´¸.·*´¨) ¸.·*¨)
    (¸.·´ (¸.·Excellent Italian Food! I'm sorry I didn't find Michael's sooner. We have 2 favorite Italian restaurants (Bay View and Milwaukee East Side). This great find is 10 minutes from home. We will be regular's in no time. A must try for anyone who loves Italian Food! The BEST Eggplant Parmesan I ever had!

    thumb Elaine Williams